30-Story Tower Proposed At Clevelander On Ocean Drive Under New Florida Law

The owner of the The Clevelander Hotel and Bar on South Beach’s famed Ocean Drive has announced plans to build a 30-story tower using a newly enacted Florida law.

Under Florida’s new Live Local Act, which went into effect July 1, developers can bypass restrictive local zoning rules by promising to build workforce housing, with the intent to make housing more accessible and affordable.

150 residential units per acre are permitted under the new law. A total of 40% must be income-restricted units affordable to workforce residents, for a period of 30 years.

“We are now facing a severe labor crisis in Miami Beach’s hospitality industry,” said Clevelander spokesperson and Shutts & Bowen attorney Alexander Tachmes. “It is extremely difficult to attract and retain talent in an industry with a dwindling labor pool and nowhere for existing employees to live.”

Owner Jesta Group says it has already hired a “prominent” architect for the new development, with plans to meet with the City to submit architectural plans in the coming days.

The development would be built on the site of the Clevelander and adjoining Essex House hotel, both owned by Jesta.

“Since purchasing the Clevelander Hotel and Bar a few years ago, we have been proud to operate this legendary and iconic establishment in South Beach. Although we are happy to continue operating as we have, some have expressed a desire that we change our business model at the property. With the Live Local Act, we now have a unique opportunity to do that. The Act allows us to redevelop the Clevelander and Essex House sites with enough density and square footage to justify the shift in our business model while providing an important public service in the form of affordable housing,” said Anthony O’Brien, Senior Managing Director of Jesta Group. “We are excited at the unique opportunity to offer true affordable housing on South Beach which will remain in place for decades to come.”

 

 

158 Comments
most voted
newest oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Name
21 days ago

I thought South Beach oceanfront was landmarked. What a shame if this gets approved.

Anon
21 days ago

The historic portion is being preserved.

Anonymous
21 days ago

And you believe that?

anon
21 days ago

It’s clearly shown in the rendering above – and mentioned in the official press release…

Anon
21 days ago

Renderings are always 100% accurate 🤡

Urbanist
21 days ago

We need many more houses in Miami Beach to solve the affordability crisis we have in Miami.

However, we should think about having the beach set up like a wedding cake where the buildings near the ocean are 8 floors, then add 4 floors every block so the buildings do not block the sun like in Sunny Isles — which literally lacks sun after noon.

That said, we need more homes in this region. We are not building enough.

anon
21 days ago

skycrapers /= affordable housing. its impossible to building a tower thats affordable due to construction cost.

Anón
21 days ago

Maybe you’re unfamiliar with how affordable housing is built, but it is 100% possible and has been done. Let’s use Google before we say crazy things.

Anonymous
21 days ago

You believe everything you Google?

anon
21 days ago

Er, no. You’re not actually getting your news from google….you’re getting it from publications that google is aggregating for you based on your prompt.

Sven
20 days ago

I think that he was being kind and generous.
He doesn’t expect that you would have the motivation to take a Development 101 class, listen to someone who knows what they are talking about, or to read a book on the subject matter.
The expectation is that if you know so little now, then you are lazy and would only be bothered to use your computer browser.

Anonymous
21 days ago

Taking some of the most valuable land in the USA to make affordable housing lol. What happens 15 years from now when millions of dollars of concrete restoration is needed from the saltwater spray? What about windstorm insurance costs on the barrier island?There’s reasons why affordable housing is in places like Sweetwater and Hialeah and Allapattah.

Sven
20 days ago

This is brilliant.
For decades Miami Beach gov’t has been talk, talk, talking about workforce/affordable housing. Now, the State of Florida takes action to allow the private sector to make it happen, and armchair planners and developers just can not square what is happening here.

As for those incredible questions:
What happens in 15 years……? If there is a problem, yo, they’ll solve it.
What about insurance…..? The owner pays it.

The play for the hospitality company is that they dedicate 40% of the apartments to their own workforce (get it yet), and they dedicate 60% to extraordinarily priced ocean view serviced apartments with beach and ocean views.

Putting micro units with an alley view allows for the density bonus, AND the workers do not have to commute from Sweetwater, Hialeah, and Allapattah.

Anon
20 days ago

Does the Clevelander owner pay Sven per sentence or per point made? Asking for my spotter at the gym.

Fern
20 days ago

I sincerely doubt they would have proposed this if it did not turn out to be profitable.

Anon
19 days ago

Profitable–made so at taxpayer expense.

Se me paro'
21 days ago

And you call yourself urbanist?
Imagine if you would say the same thing about NYC, London, Paris, Tokyo?
More homes????
Leave that for the outer suburbs….

anon
21 days ago

People are saying that about all of those cities…there is a proposal to literally add hundreds of acres of land to lower Manhattan.

Anon
21 days ago

Exactly! Stagger the city up, with Miami Beach being the lowest village area.

Anonymous
21 days ago

We are adding tons of homes in land in Miami

Anonymous
21 days ago

Ocean Drive is iconic and known all over the world. It represents south Florida to people everywhere. Something of this scale is out of place and would damage the image of the area. This would be a better fit on Alton or West Ave. or further north. It does not belong on Ocean Drive or anywhere near it.

Anonymous
21 days ago

This would mark the beginning of the end for South Beach

Urbanist
21 days ago

Disagree — allowing more people to live in the part of the region with the highest demand is literally letting the market meet some of the demand. This is a great project.

anon
21 days ago

Sorry, you have this backwards.

Adding housing means adding long-term residents. In order to transform South Beach from a ratchet Air-BnB wasteland to a thriving, safe, year-round city we need to add long term residents, and minimize the transient-stays.

Less Air-BnB, more long term residents is a good thing.

Jeremey Howlett
21 days ago

I actually like it’s ratchetness, it’s the only place you can really go and see all the different races mixing, having a great time etc. If you don’t like the vibe maybe you need to hangout in ft. Lauderdale, west palm beach, or all the other picture perfect cities.

Anonymous
20 days ago

Exactly! Move to Brickell if you want an orderly sophisticated city environment.

Sven
20 days ago

Did you not read the article?
The Clevelander HOTEL is adding apartments for workers.

“We need”???
The history of Miami Beach, and my experience from living there for over 20 years, is that the HOTELS and transient hospitality business is what allows for many of the residents to enjoy the amenities that exist today. Joe’s Stone Crabs has ALWAYS been a staple for tourists. The fact that there are so many tourists is why the locals are able to enjoy the $12 whole chicken.

Tourists create an incredible demand to allow for businesses to thrive, and locals are the beneficiary.

Augusto
19 days ago

Your ratchet air bnb is the largest Art Deco city in the world. This is about greed.

Really
21 days ago

So if you’re a low income worker and work in the hospitality industry you’re a bum will cause problems?! Most of those people are much nicer and more respectful than a lot of well to do people not too mention all the Airbnb party trash people that visit.

Fern
20 days ago

The rent for the subsidized units will be two grand per month. Anyone who can afford that will be a normal person with a good job

Anonymous
21 days ago

ocean drive is one of the most iconic streets in america and will be ruined by this towering building and that is just the beginning. Developers need to be stopped, otherwise they will ruin all our iconic neighborhoods

Urbanist
21 days ago

Where are people going to live? We should not push further into the everglades with more development. We need more density where people want to live – and people want to live near the beach. Build more housing.

Anon
21 days ago

You’re shilling real hard for a subsidized life on the beach.

Anón
21 days ago

Crazy how wanting people to have homes to live in for our growing region is seen as a bad thing.

If you don’t like development, you’re in the wrong city, county, state, and country.

Anon
21 days ago

If you want a home on fancy Ocean Drive, pay for 100% of it your self.

anon
21 days ago

like 90% of miami beach 2 storeys lol literally just building 6 storeys like every other important city on the planet built before 1930. skycrapers dont add affordable housing, the height means the core has to be huge making the units expensive.

TLR
20 days ago

Yes

Anonymous
21 days ago

Everyone wants to live on the beach, but few can afford to. So they live where they can afford. And taxpayers should not subsidize beach living—it’s a luxury.

anon
21 days ago

The entire city is on the beach…it’s literally called “Miami Beach”

Huh
21 days ago

It’s like Staten Island, except instead of being a part of Miami it’s a destination town with out transportation…. It’s more like Coney Island

Anon
21 days ago

Staten Island is like Cleveland with a bigger river next to it. Miami Beach is like a tropical paradise.

Anonymous
20 days ago

“The entire city is on the beach…” no shit Dickless Tracy

Anonymous
21 days ago

Nobody wants to live there except grifters and dead beats. It’s fun play land for people coming for a weekend. Move to the city.

Anon
21 days ago

^^wrong

Anonymous
20 days ago

Nobody wants to live in Miami Beach….which is why tiny tract houses along Alton Rd start at $2million.

Sven
20 days ago

Nobody buys houses in Miami Beach anymore the demand is too high.

3100 N Bay Road sold for $1.4M in 2001.
3100 N Bay Road sold for $13.6M in 2023 and it will be torn down to build a new home.

TLR
20 days ago

Yes

Sven
20 days ago

How exactly are “taxpayers subsidizing” this?
These private property owners are navigating the law in order to build something on their private property.
OPPOSITE of being subsidized by taxpayers, they are increasing the value of the property, and increasing the Property Tax Bill that will be paid every single year for the next 100 years and beyond.

Opposite of a taxpayer subsidy, these property owners propose ADDING taxes to the tax base above and beyond what exists today.

Anon
20 days ago

https://www.flgov.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Live-Local-Act.pdf

Who’s paying for that? Gee I wonder who?

If this SB102 program wasn’t such a gravy train, then the developer would be proposing 100% market rate. Guess why they aren’t? Guess who pays the difference?

Anon
21 days ago

Move to Homestead! It’s cheep there.

Anon
21 days ago

We want development where people want to be.

You just don’t seem to understand that for some reason.

Anon
21 days ago

People want to be where you develop. You can develop anywhere in Miami and get the same price for it if you do it nicely.

Anonymous
21 days ago

You just don’t seem to understand you’re an entitled prick.

Anon
21 days ago

💯😂😂

anon
21 days ago

It’s spelled “cheap.”

Anonymous
21 days ago

There are lots of places on the beach where developers can build high rises like the area behind Alton Road facing biscayne bay but they should leave ocean drive alone

TLR
20 days ago

Agree

TLR
20 days ago

Could they commute to work

Robert Smith
19 days ago

>Where are people going to live? We should not push further into the everglades with more development
How about the massive swathes of land of warehouses and single family housing and ground level open parking lots. Not everyone in the NYC area gets to live in the heart of Manhattan- build up the surrounding area like literally every real city on the planet. Doing this makes those surrounding areas desirable in their own right (see: Brooklyn). Rome, Vienna, Copenhagen, Budapest, Prague etc have way less skyscrapers or big office towers yet the density of people walking the streets and living is way more than SFL currently. Imagine if Little Havana…actually looked kinda like Havana with its architecture and multi-level midsized buildings instead of basically being strip malls

Augusto
19 days ago

Yes, more housing. But not in Ocean Drive!

Downtowner
21 days ago

Whether it’s for luxury apartments or affordable housing, a 30-story building does not belong on Ocean Drive.

TLR
20 days ago

Correct

NOPE
21 days ago

comment image

Anonn
21 days ago

Big time no

Shawn Kouri
21 days ago

No way. No way Jose. This was all part of the plan to convert and demolish historic buildings on Ocean Drive and turn them into high-rise buildings in their place. We cannot allow that. This is something that preservationists did not want.

Urbanist
21 days ago

You can preserve the historic buildings and add density in a smart way. Allow development.

Anon
21 days ago

Not THIS kind of development

Anón
21 days ago

Just say you don’t like development and move somewhere without any.

Anon
21 days ago

Just say you’re low key hoping for subsidized living on America’s hottest street.

Anón
21 days ago

Just say you hate poor people and they don’t deserve housing.

I’m sure you’re a lovely person who then complains about un-housed people while blocking new housing.

Make it make sense.

Anon
21 days ago

Just say you want a handout. Nobody deserves Ocean Drive South Beach housing.

Sven
20 days ago

The private property owners disagree with you or they would not be making this proposal.

Intelligent business people understand the importance of talent acquisition and retention. When you are running a hotel/restaurant such as the Clevelander, these things are especially important.

Attracting managers, servers, housekeepers to rent in 40% of your building and work in your building at the same time makes a lot of sense.

The cult of “get the cars off the road” should be ecstatic.

Anon
20 days ago

It’s a giveaway to developers, paid for by taxpayers, most of whom cannot live on market rate Ocean Drive, in order to fund the Ocean Drive living for those who also cannot.

Anonymous
21 days ago

So instead, giant elongated squat boxes, like that one project on Washington Avenue? Bleh…

Anonymous
21 days ago

We don’t need density on Miamk Beach It’s not the urban core! It’s a vacation spot and getaway for people in the city. Add density to the core

anon
21 days ago

Miami Beach is literally it’s own separate city, in and of itself. It has it’s OWN core.

Anon
21 days ago

It’s a resort beach town / not a fully functioning economic city center. They can’t thrive together like that.

Anon
20 days ago

If it has a core, it should be around the new metro stop, not haphazardly upzoned in the most historical district in the United States of America.

TLR
20 days ago

True

TLR
20 days ago

Yes

TLR
20 days ago

Just the beginning …you are correct

Anonymous
21 days ago

Amazing how everyone is for development until they twist like a pretzel and are against it.

bob art guy
21 days ago

Would that put a 30 story tower in front of the Statue of Liberty, Mount Rushmore – This really has to be prevented. That image is Ocean Drive is an iconic representation of our country. Let stop this craziness ASAP

Anon
21 days ago

Miami Beach has changed, and some folks are worried about rowdy behavior, like twerking on fake cars 🤢 Brickell/Downtown has been attracting more LGBTQ+ and sophisticated crowds, because of its evolving vibe in comparison to deteriorating scene on South Beach. Most residents want to keep Miami Beach special and not lose its unique charm.

Name*
21 days ago

Guys the population of Miami Beach has actually been going down slightly for decades now. It’s actually a small town of only 80,000 people but with a lot of tourists like Ocean City MD or Myrtle Beach. It has a reverse commute like a downtown area where the population swells in the day vs at night for residential areas. Even though it has a lot of small hotels and like three big ones.

anon
21 days ago

It frightens me thinking about how many of these commenters vote.

calivalle
21 days ago

30 story if your going to mess up the vibe on the beach.. Go ahead and put up a 100 story.Developers are going to anyway..

Kitty w
21 days ago

This seems like it’s setting up a case to challenge the new law, no?

Cover the Podiums
21 days ago

I’m sure they can make amendments to this new law. Go build that 30 story building in downtown where it actually needs redevelopment and 30 stories makes sense.

BB1
21 days ago

This is a huge F you to Miami Beach for changing last call times.

Anonymous
21 days ago

💯

Sven
20 days ago

I would agree that this “proposal” is designed for that.
Now the politicians who clamor for gov’t housing, gov’t transportation to Miami Beach, will have to explain why housing is no longer important.

The solution is probably going to be transfer development rights from Ocean Drive to Washington Ave.

For what it is worth, the Continuum Towers at the southern point of Ocean Drive are 40 Stories and 37 stories.

Anonymous
20 days ago

Impeach DeSantis, another developer and big money puppet! Out of touch with the urban environments in Florida

MiamiRob
19 days ago

This is what happens when you Elect Republican pro-Development developers to be your Lawmakers instead.

Fern
20 days ago

This is a good thing. I don’t think people realize that rent-restricted housing in Miami Beach is set to one-third of 120% the Area Median Income. In that city it’ll be about $2000 a month. These are not bums or drug addicts that would live there! They would be normal people with good jobs

Augusto
19 days ago

Unbelievable. Under this law Art Deco District is in danger of falling to the greed. Affordable housing in Ocean Drive? Find another excuse to destroy the art deco district.

Anonymous
20 days ago

Looks like Clevelander put their plant on TNM under the name Urbanist to spew their case. So blaring obvious.

Anon
19 days ago

💯yes

Anon
19 days ago

All the upvotes against this project got turned to downvotes like just overnight. Sven and Urbanist clearly on their payroll.

Jeremey Howlett
15 days ago

All the properties between Alton rd and west ave are prime for developments with heights of 500 plus ft.

GAwd
15 days ago

Don’t worry though, all this affordable living talk is going to end next year when all the NSA gang members get removed from government, and some from this country.

Pedro
21 days ago

Miami-Dade is the most rent burdened region in the country and people are upset at a 40% affordable housing mandate? Come on people, this is a working city, if you want an empty beach move to Melbourne.

Anonymous
21 days ago

Why not build it more in land then? Wouldn’t it also be cheaper? Why do affordable buildings need to be built in a prime ocean front location?

Urbanist
21 days ago

We do not need to build on more land further out into the everglades – that is a known issue that will have disastrous consequences. Build where people want to live.

Sven
20 days ago

Because the private property owners want to have the freedom and liberty to do what they can within the law.

Mayor Gelber wants to take their private property rights away.

Go read up on the Burt Harris Act.
https://www.floridabar.org/the-florida-bar-journal/the-bert-j-harris-jr-private-property-rights-protection-act-an-overview-recent-developments-and-what-the-future-may-hold/

Anon
20 days ago

Your private property rights stop where my tax dollar spending starts getting involved. Developers do not have carte blanche rights to a taxpayer-funded giveaway program.

Anon
21 days ago

If you want cheap housing on the beach move to Melbourne.

Urbanist
21 days ago

So the people who are making your coffee need to commute from Melbourne?

How does that make any sense?

Anon
21 days ago

So the low wage no skill people making you coffee get taxpayer help to live in a nicer location than your own middle-class self can afford.

How does that make any sense?

Sven
20 days ago

Taxpayer help?
Subsidies?

The private property owner is building apartments, on his own dime, there are no subsidies.

Most of those whining about “subsides” and taxpayer help are strong advocates of the taxpayer subsidized capital expenditures necessary to build a Metromover on top of an existing bus route, AND for taxpayer subsidies every single year that the Metromover operations cannot be self-sustainable.

Some of you people really have no idea what you are writing about; you should be ashamed of your woeful ignorance and ashamed of your burden to society.

Anon
20 days ago

^^Look up The Live Local Tax Credit program. Guess who’s paying for that tax credit? Everyone else is, Einstein. Either you ae purposely deceitful with an agenda or you’re truly lame.

Anonymous
21 days ago

They can commute from Hialeah and North Miami. Instead of getting subsidized homes in the middle of America’s trendiest neighborhood.

How can you not see that?

Anonymous
21 days ago

This is Americas trendiest vacation spot, keep it charming – people don’t want to live in Miami Beach! It’s isolated as is!

Anonymous
20 days ago

LOTS of people want to live in Miami Beach, but few can afford it.

Lobo
20 days ago

Nope huh no way negative.

Anonymous
19 days ago

Sven and Urbanist clearly on the developers take. What a joke.

Anon
21 days ago

The mayor of Miami Beach said he will do everything in his power to keep this from happening – it’s all a part of dumb DeSantis live local law which arbitrarily strips local governments from the authority to manage growth.

Anonymous
21 days ago

False, it’s in lieu of bogus policies certain local governments push that have keep being tried and never work, like rent control and inclusionary zoning. Whether it works, we’ll see.

Anonymous
21 days ago

This should never be allowed even as a thought. Affordable housing should never be in a prime location.

Urbanist
21 days ago

Poor people don’t deserve to live near their jobs? What soviet-style master planning do you have in mind? They must live far away from everything? That literally makes no sense.

Anonymous
21 days ago

Plenty of wealthy people live far from their jobs too. And people working restaurant jobs tend to last an average of like 3 months at their jobs before quitting or getting fired. They’re always on the move.

Anonymous
21 days ago

In America you live where you can afford, not where you think you deserve to.

Anonymous
21 days ago

If they are a farmer sure, but if they chose to serve people in rich areas then they have to commute

Anonymous
21 days ago

So, by your logic, all lifeguards should have an ocean front condo lmao

Anonymous
20 days ago

Good bartenders and waiters at top Miami Beach establishments make quite good money, enough to afford small apartments along Meridian Ave. Not all of them make $15/hr, esp. those working in Miami Beach.

Anonymous
21 days ago

All of Miami is a prime location. Affordable housing should be above the core in edgwater and wynwood

anon
21 days ago

Miami Beach is a separate city. It has it’s own core.

Anonymous
21 days ago

Those are prime locations too

TLR
20 days ago

True statement

Befuddled
21 days ago

This is horrifying.

Anonymous
21 days ago

Affordable housing belongs on Miami Beach – it’s the Staten Island of Miami! The chic real estate is in Brickell and Downtown.

Anon
21 days ago

🤡😂🤡

Anonymous
21 days ago

Staten Island is all luxury villas though, not much affordable housing there.

SoreBe
21 days ago

Staten Island has a ferry at least. What’s SoBe have but Brazilian butt lifts and over priced food?

Jeremey Howlett
21 days ago

I think it makes more sense to build workforce housing in Miami around metro rail stations and extend the metro rail into Miami Beach. Most workers don’t want to live above a 24 hour party district, and there’s plenty of affordable housing spread across the city. It’s called old housing units. People need to start at the bottom and work their way up, that’s how they learn to appreciate things more. Plus, affordable housing is like the projects from back in the days. It doesn’t work, that’s why they got rid of them.

Anonymous
20 days ago

Yes, but the Entitled Pricks segment want subsidized Ocean Drive living.

Sven
20 days ago

The proposal is to include 40% of the apartments for workforce/affordable.
60% is market rate.

Miami Beach does have workforce/affordable housing, it has been run by the City Gov’t for decades and has survived through corruption and scandal.